Boise: Is City Chlorine Burning Summer Youth?
By Franklin Everett ShawThe chlorine smell hits you hard as you walk into the Natatorium in Boise. It’s a familiar scent, a promise of clean water and summer fun. But for some Boise families, that smell is a trigger, a harbinger of itchy skin, red eyes, and breathing difficulties for their kids. Is Boise’s water chlorination to blame? And what can parents do to protect their children?
Boise, Idaho, like many municipalities, uses chlorine to disinfect its water supply. This process kills harmful bacteria and viruses, making the water safe to drink and swim in. The City of Boise Water Renewal Services diligently monitors water quality, adhering to EPA standards for chlorine levels. However, even within safe limits, chlorine can react with organic matter in the water to form disinfection byproducts (DBPs) like trihalomethanes (THMs) and haloacetic acids (HAAs). These DBPs, along with chlorine itself, can irritate the skin and respiratory system, especially in sensitive individuals.
Children are particularly vulnerable. Their skin is thinner and more permeable than adults, allowing for greater absorption of chemicals. They also breathe faster, inhaling more chlorine vapors, especially during vigorous swimming. This can exacerbate existing conditions like asthma or eczema.
So, is Boise’s water uniquely problematic? Not necessarily. But several factors can contribute to increased exposure and sensitivity in Boise:
- Summer Heat: Boise summers are hot and dry. This leads to increased water usage, potentially requiring higher chlorine levels to maintain disinfection.
- Outdoor Swimming: Boise boasts numerous outdoor pools and splash pads. Prolonged exposure to sunlight can further react with chlorine, increasing DBP formation.
- Individual Sensitivity: Some children are simply more sensitive to chlorine than others. Genetics, pre-existing skin conditions, and overall health can play a role.
What can concerned parents in Boise do? Here’s a practical, multi-pronged approach:
1. Water Testing (Beyond the Tap):
Don’t just rely on the city’s reports. Invest in a home water testing kit specifically designed to measure chlorine and DBPs. You can find these at local hardware stores like Lowe’s on Milwaukee Street or online retailers. Test your tap water and the water at your child’s favorite swimming pool or splash pad. This gives you a baseline understanding of the chlorine levels they’re exposed to.
2. Safer Swimming Practices:
- Pre-Swim Shower: Encourage your child to shower before entering the pool. This removes sweat, dirt, and lotions that can react with chlorine, reducing DBP formation.
- Protective Barrier: Apply a thick layer of a barrier cream like Aquaphor or Vaseline to your child’s skin before swimming. This creates a physical barrier against chlorine absorption.
- Swim Cap and Goggles: Protect hair and eyes from chlorine exposure.
- Post-Swim Rinse: Immediately after swimming, rinse your child thoroughly with clean, non-chlorinated water. Use a gentle, chlorine-neutralizing soap like those containing Vitamin C.
- Limit Exposure Time: Reduce the amount of time your child spends in chlorinated water, especially during peak sunlight hours.
3. Alternative Hydration Strategies:
Chlorine exposure isn’t just from swimming. It’s also in our drinking water. While Boise’s water is safe, sensitive children might benefit from alternative hydration strategies:
- Filtered Water: Use a high-quality water filter certified to remove chlorine and DBPs. Brita filters, available at Target on Fairview Avenue, are a common option, but consider a more robust filter like a Berkey for greater DBP removal.
- Spring Water: Opt for bottled spring water, ensuring it’s from a reputable source.
- Hydrating Foods: Supplement water intake with hydrating fruits and vegetables like watermelon, cucumbers, and berries, readily available at the Boise Co-op.
4. Local Boise Resources:
- Boise City Water Renewal Services: Contact them directly with questions about water quality and chlorination practices. Their website provides detailed information and contact details.
- Local Pediatricians: Consult with your pediatrician about your child’s sensitivity to chlorine. They can recommend specific treatments and strategies. Many practices are located near St. Luke’s Boise Medical Center.
- Idaho Department of Environmental Quality (DEQ): If you suspect a serious water quality issue, contact the DEQ. They are responsible for monitoring and enforcing environmental regulations.
- Boise Aquatics Center: Reach out to the management of the Boise Aquatics Center to inquire about their chlorine monitoring practices and any measures they take to minimize DBP formation.
5. Advocating for Improved Water Quality:
Individual actions are important, but collective action can drive real change.
- Attend City Council Meetings: Voice your concerns about chlorine levels and DBPs at Boise City Council meetings.
- Support Local Organizations: Support organizations advocating for cleaner water and environmental health in Boise.
- Educate Others: Share information about chlorine sensitivity and safer swimming practices with other parents in your community.
Common Mistakes and Pitfalls:
- Assuming “Safe” Means "Harmless": Just because Boise’s water meets EPA standards doesn’t mean it’s harmless to everyone. Individual sensitivities vary.
- Ignoring Indoor Air Quality: Chlorine vapors can accumulate in indoor swimming pool environments. Ensure adequate ventilation.
- Over-Reliance on Chlorine Neutralizing Products: While helpful, these products are not a substitute for other preventative measures.
- Not Testing Pool Water: Public pools are supposed to be monitored, but it’s wise to test the water yourself, especially if you notice a strong chlorine smell or your child experiences irritation.
- Using Hot Water for Post-Swim Rinse: Hot water can open pores and increase chlorine absorption. Use lukewarm or cool water.
Real-World Scenario:
Imagine Sarah, a Boise mom whose 6-year-old son, Liam, develops a persistent rash after swimming at the local YMCA pool. Sarah initially dismisses it as “pool rash,” but the rash worsens, and Liam starts coughing. Sarah, armed with the information above, takes the following steps:
- She purchases a water testing kit and tests both her tap water and the YMCA pool water. She discovers that the pool’s chlorine levels are at the higher end of the acceptable range.
- She starts having Liam shower before and after swimming, applying Aquaphor beforehand and using a chlorine-neutralizing soap afterward.
- She limits Liam’s swimming time and encourages him to drink filtered water throughout the day.
- She contacts the YMCA management to inquire about their chlorine monitoring practices and suggests they consider alternative disinfection methods.
- She consults with Liam’s pediatrician, who confirms that he has a mild chlorine sensitivity and recommends a topical steroid cream for the rash.
Within a week, Liam’s rash clears up, and his coughing subsides. Sarah’s proactive approach, combined with the pediatrician’s guidance, allows Liam to continue enjoying swimming without the negative side effects.
Boise’s water is generally safe, but chlorine sensitivity is a real concern for some families. By understanding the potential risks, taking proactive steps, and advocating for improved water quality, parents in Boise can help their children enjoy the benefits of swimming without compromising their health. Don’t just accept the chlorine smell as a necessary evil; empower yourself with knowledge and take action to protect your family.