Phoenix Pools: Tap Shock Nuking Baby Livers?
By Franklin Everett ShawThe desert sun beats down, and the shimmering blue of a pool beckons. But beneath that inviting surface, a hidden danger lurks, especially for the most vulnerable among us: infants and toddlers. We’re not talking about drowning; we’re talking about the chemical byproducts formed when we “shock” our pools to keep them clean, and how Phoenix’s unique climate exacerbates the problem.
Pool shocking, the process of adding a large dose of chlorine to kill bacteria and algae, is a common practice in Phoenix, where the intense heat and sunlight can quickly turn a pristine pool into a breeding ground for unwanted organisms. While necessary, this process creates disinfection byproducts (DBPs) like trihalomethanes (THMs) and haloacetic acids (HAAs). These chemicals, formed when chlorine reacts with organic matter (sweat, sunscreen, leaves, etc.), are linked to a range of health problems, from respiratory issues to, in some studies, increased cancer risk with long-term exposure.
Infants and toddlers are particularly susceptible. Their smaller body size means a higher dose per kilogram of body weight, and their developing organs are more vulnerable to chemical damage. They also tend to swallow more pool water than adults, increasing their exposure.
So, what can concerned Phoenix parents do? The good news is that you’re not powerless. With knowledge and proactive measures, you can significantly reduce your family’s exposure to these harmful chemicals.
First, test your water. Don’t rely solely on the pool maintenance company or community pool staff. Invest in a home testing kit specifically designed to measure THMs and HAAs. These kits are readily available online or at pool supply stores. Look for kits that provide quantitative results, not just a simple “pass/fail” indication. Taylor Technologies and Hach are reputable brands. A good starting point is the Taylor Technologies K-2006 test kit, supplemented with a DPD chlorine test for accurate free chlorine readings.
- Take multiple samples from different areas of the pool.
- Test at different times of day, especially after periods of heavy use or shocking.
- Compare your results to the EPA’s maximum contaminant levels (MCLs) for drinking water, which, while not directly applicable to pool water, provide a useful benchmark. The MCL for total THMs is 80 parts per billion (ppb), and for HAAs, it’s 60 ppb.
If your test results reveal elevated levels of THMs or HAAs, don’t panic. There are several proven methods for mitigating these chemicals, and many are particularly effective in the dry Arizona climate.
Ventilation is key, especially for indoor pools or enclosed pool areas. THMs are volatile and readily evaporate into the air. Increasing ventilation helps to remove these chemicals from the air, reducing inhalation exposure.
- Open windows and doors whenever possible.
- Install exhaust fans to draw out contaminated air.
- Consider a whole-house ventilation system with heat recovery to improve air quality without significantly increasing energy costs.
Filtration is your friend. Activated carbon filters are highly effective at removing THMs and HAAs from pool water.
- Install a whole-pool carbon filtration system. These systems can be expensive, but they provide the most comprehensive protection.
- Use a carbon filter attachment for your garden hose when filling or topping off the pool. This will remove DBPs from the source water.
- Regularly backwash your filter to remove accumulated organic matter, which contributes to DBP formation.
Optimize your pool chemistry. Maintaining proper chlorine levels is essential for disinfection, but excessive chlorine can lead to increased DBP formation.
- Use a saltwater chlorinator instead of traditional chlorine tablets. Saltwater systems produce chlorine more consistently and at lower levels, reducing the risk of over-chlorination.
- Consider using alternative sanitizers like ozone or UV systems. These systems can reduce the need for chlorine, minimizing DBP formation. However, they should be used in conjunction with chlorine, not as a complete replacement.
- Regularly test and adjust your pool’s pH, alkalinity, and calcium hardness. Imbalances in these parameters can affect chlorine’s effectiveness and increase DBP formation.
Reduce organic matter. The less organic matter in your pool, the fewer DBPs will form.
- Encourage swimmers to shower before entering the pool to remove sweat, sunscreen, and other contaminants.
- Regularly skim the pool surface to remove leaves, insects, and other debris.
- Use a pool cover when the pool is not in use to prevent debris from entering the water.
Be mindful of shocking practices. While shocking is sometimes necessary, avoid over-shocking.
- Only shock the pool when necessary, based on water testing results.
- Use the appropriate amount of chlorine for the pool’s volume.
- Shock the pool at night to minimize chlorine loss due to sunlight.
A common pitfall is neglecting to address the source water. Phoenix’s municipal water supply can contain pre-existing DBPs. Filling your pool with this water without pre-filtration simply adds to the problem. Always use a carbon filter when filling or topping off your pool.
Another challenge is the “out of sight, out of mind” mentality. Many pool owners assume that if the water looks clear, it’s safe. This is a dangerous assumption. DBPs are invisible and odorless. Regular testing is the only way to know for sure.
Don’t rely solely on pool service companies. While many companies provide excellent service, they may not prioritize DBP mitigation. Take responsibility for your family’s health and actively monitor your pool’s water quality.
Consider the microclimate around your pool. In Phoenix, pools are often surrounded by concrete or pavers, which can radiate heat and increase water temperature. Higher water temperatures can accelerate DBP formation. Shade structures, such as pergolas or umbrellas, can help to reduce water temperature and minimize DBP formation.
Finally, educate yourself and others. Share this information with your neighbors, friends, and community pool managers. The more people who are aware of the risks of DBPs, the safer our pools will be for everyone, especially our children.
By taking these proactive steps, Phoenix parents can enjoy their pools without compromising their children’s health. It requires effort and vigilance, but the peace of mind is well worth it. Remember, a sparkling pool doesn’t always mean a safe pool. Knowledge is power, and in this case, it’s the power to protect your family.