Taos Trackers: Altitude Lies About Summer Calories?
By Franklin Everett ShawForget the step counters and heart rate monitors you see advertised on late-night TV. They’re often useless, especially if you live in a place like Taos, New Mexico.
Fitness trackers are ubiquitous. We strap them on, sync them up, and trustingly accept the data they spit out. But what if that data is fundamentally flawed, skewed by something as simple as where you live?
This is the reality for many residents of high-altitude locations like Taos, New Mexico, and other mountainous regions across the U.S. The thin air and unique physiological demands of living at elevation throw a major wrench into the accuracy of these devices.
Let’s dive into why your fitness tracker might be lying to you, and what you can do about it, especially if you call a high-altitude town home.
The core issue is oxygen. At higher altitudes, the partial pressure of oxygen is lower. This means your body has to work harder to extract the same amount of oxygen from each breath. This increased effort translates to a higher heart rate and a greater caloric expenditure for the same activity compared to sea level.
Most fitness trackers rely on algorithms that estimate calorie burn based on factors like heart rate, steps taken, and user-inputted data like age, weight, and gender. They don’t directly measure oxygen consumption.
Because they don’t account for the reduced oxygen availability at altitude, they often underestimate the true number of calories burned. This can lead to frustration, inaccurate nutritional planning, and potentially hinder your fitness goals.
Consider this: a brisk walk in Taos (elevation 6,969 feet) might feel significantly more strenuous than the same walk at sea level. Your heart rate will likely be higher, and you’ll probably be breathing harder. However, your fitness tracker might not fully reflect this increased effort, leading you to believe you burned fewer calories than you actually did.
This isn’t just a theoretical problem. I spoke with several residents of Taos who shared their experiences. Maria, a local hiking enthusiast, noted that her fitness tracker consistently underestimated her calorie burn during mountain hikes. “I knew I was working harder than the tracker indicated,” she said. “I was constantly hungry, even though the app said I was within my calorie goals.”
Another resident, David, a cyclist, found that his tracker’s calorie estimations were wildly inaccurate when he compared them to his power meter data. “The power meter is a much more precise measure of work output,” he explained. “The fitness tracker was consistently off by hundreds of calories, especially on uphill climbs.”
So, what can you do to get more accurate data from your fitness tracker at high altitude? Here are some actionable steps:
Adjust Your Activity Level: Most trackers allow you to set an activity level (sedentary, lightly active, moderately active, very active). If you live at high altitude, consider bumping your activity level up a notch. This will tell the tracker to expect a higher baseline calorie burn.
Calibrate Your Stride Length: Accurate step counting is crucial for calorie estimation. At altitude, you might naturally shorten your stride length due to the increased effort. Measure your actual stride length and manually input it into your tracker’s settings. To do this, walk a known distance (e.g., 100 feet) and count your steps. Divide the distance by the number of steps to get your stride length.
Use a Heart Rate Monitor with External Sensors: While the wrist-based heart rate sensors on most fitness trackers are convenient, they can be less accurate, especially during intense activity or in cold weather. Consider using a chest strap heart rate monitor, which provides more reliable data. Some advanced trackers also allow you to connect external sensors like power meters (for cycling) or foot pods (for running), which can provide more accurate data on speed, distance, and cadence.
Monitor Your Body’s Signals: Pay attention to how you feel. Are you consistently hungry, even though your tracker says you’re eating enough? Are you feeling fatigued or experiencing performance plateaus? These could be signs that you’re not consuming enough calories to fuel your activity at altitude.
Consult with a Local Expert: A registered dietitian or certified personal trainer in Taos (or any high-altitude location) can provide personalized guidance on adjusting your calorie intake and training plan based on your individual needs and activity level. They understand the unique challenges of exercising at altitude and can help you optimize your fitness tracking and nutritional planning.
Experiment and Track Your Progress: Keep a detailed food journal and track your weight, body composition, and performance metrics (e.g., running pace, cycling power). Adjust your calorie intake and training plan based on your progress and how you feel. This iterative approach will help you fine-tune your fitness strategy for high-altitude living.
Consider a Barometric Altimeter: Some fitness trackers include a barometric altimeter, which measures changes in air pressure to estimate altitude gain and loss. This can provide more accurate data on the intensity of your workouts, especially if you’re hiking or climbing.
Don’t Rely Solely on the Tracker: Use your fitness tracker as a tool, but don’t let it dictate your every move. Listen to your body, adjust your calorie intake based on your hunger levels, and focus on overall health and well-being rather than obsessing over the numbers on your wrist.
One common pitfall is blindly trusting the tracker’s calorie estimations without considering the environmental factors. Another mistake is failing to adjust the tracker’s settings to account for your individual characteristics and activity level.
To overcome these challenges, be proactive in calibrating your tracker, monitoring your body’s signals, and seeking expert advice. Remember, fitness trackers are just tools, and they’re not always perfect.
Living and exercising at high altitude presents unique challenges, but it also offers incredible opportunities for fitness and adventure. By understanding the limitations of fitness trackers and taking steps to adjust for altitude, you can get more accurate data, optimize your training, and achieve your fitness goals, even in the thin air of Taos, New Mexico.
Ultimately, the best approach is to combine the data from your fitness tracker with your own intuition and experience. Listen to your body, adjust your calorie intake as needed, and enjoy the journey.